transcript   Transcript

Trademark Fair Use: Update and Overview

Recorded on: Dec. 12, 2016
Running Time: 01:03:00

Full Transcript:

If you are a Privileged Member, just log in and start reading now! If you are not a Privileged Member, please click here to learn how unlimited access to PLI programs may be right for you and your firm.

To access the streaming media of this presentation, please purchase the corresponding seminar segment.

Taken from the briefing Trademark Fair Use:  Update and Overview recorded December, 2016 in New York.

This Briefing will address "trademark fair use," a frequent and puzzling issue in day-to-day trademark practice. The occasion is an important 2016 opinion from the United States Second Circuit Court of Appeals, Int’l Information v. Security University, 823 F3d 153, 2016 BL 157781, __USPQ2d __ (2d Cir 2016). This case has significantly added to the jurisprudence of trademark “fair use,” in particular, “nominative fair use.” The Court reviewed precedent on the subject principally from the U.S. Supreme Court, and Third and Ninth Circuits. The Second Circuit then structured its own multi-factor test to be applied to nominative fair use cases. As part of the opinion, the Second Circuit distinguished “classic, descriptive trademark fair use” jurisprudence. The court also considered whether nominative fair use is an “affirmative defense” and the kinds of relevant evidence bearing on it.

Nominative fair use sometimes overlaps with descriptive fair use. The Briefing will also present a number of recent and oft-cited older precedents in the field. Issues include the degree of descriptiveness of the mark in question, the intent of the defendant, the fairness of the use, and whether the use is “otherwise than as a trademark.” The last question is especially difficult, being fact-driven and highly unpredictable in judicial decisions. Actual label and advertising usages from the precedent cases will be illustrated in the Briefing as examples of what courts have judged to be fair uses or not.

Lecture Topics  [01:03:00]

Listen to Laura C. Gustafson and Richard L. Kirkpatrick of Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP for a discussion on the following topics:

  • Overview of nominative and classic trademark fair use
  • Recent Second Circuit trademark case, Int’l Information v. Security University
  • U.S. Supreme Court, Third Circuit and Ninth Circuit trademark precedents
  • Illustrations of adjudicated fair uses
  • Practical pointers to defend and attack claimed fair uses

Presentation Material

  • Principles of Likelihood of Confusion
    Laura C. Gustafson, Richard L. Kirkpatrick
  • Trademark Fair Use & Likelihood of Confusion
    Laura C. Gustafson, Richard L. Kirkpatrick
Laura C Gustafson ~ Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
Richard L Kirkpatrick ~ Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
Transcript FAQ's
  • How Can I Access Transcripts?
    You must be a Member in good standing.

  • Can I access the Video?
    Yes, you can access the video if you have the Adobe Flash plugin installed. Click on the video camera icon when you mouse over each paragraph. The media will begin playback at that point.

  • Can I get CLE credit for reading the transcript?
    No, CLE credit cannot be earned for reading a transcript. CLE credit is issued only for verified attendance while watching a web program. If seeking credit, please verify the program's eligibility for credit and expiration date in your jurisdiction on the web segment launch page before commencing the program.

  • twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • GooglePlus
  • RSS

All Contents Copyright © 1996-2017 Practising Law Institute. Continuing Legal Education since 1933.

© 2017 PLI PRACTISING LAW INSTITUTE. All rights reserved. The PLI logo is a service mark of PLI.