| |
|
|
Employment Law Yearbook 2013 Table of Contents |
|
|
|
|
Introduction |
|
|
|
Chapter 1: |
Wage-and-Hour Issues |
|
|
- § 1:1 : Introduction4
- § 1:2 : The Legal Framework of Wage-and-Hour Laws5
- § 1:2.1 : Minimum Wage7
- [A] : FLSA7
- [B] : California7
- [C] : New York8
- § 1:2.2 : Overtime Exemptions9
- [A] : FLSA9
- [A][1] : Federal White Collar Overtime Regulations10
- [A][1][a] : Minimum Salary Requirement10
- [A][1][b] : Rules for “Highly Compensated” Employees10
- [A][1][c] : Salary Basis Requirement11
- [A][1][c][i] : Permissible Deductions11
- [A][1][c][ii] : Consequences of Improper Deductions12
- [A][1][c][iii] : Safe Harbor13
- [A][1][d] : White Collar Exemption14
- [A][1][d][i] : Executive Exemption14
- [A][1][d][ii] : Administrative Exemption16
- [A][1][d][iii] : Professional Exemption17
- [A][1][d][iv] : Computer Employee Exemption18
- [A][1][d][v] : Outside Sales Exemption18
- [A][2] : Commission Sales Exemption19
- [A][3] : Motor Carrier Act Exemption19
- [A][4] : Belo Plan20
- [B] : “White Collar” (New York) Exemptions21
- [C] : California Exemptions22
- [C][1] : Executive Exemption22
- [C][2] : Administrative Exemption22
- [C][3] : Professional Exemption25
- [C][4] : Outside Sales Exemption26
- [C][5] : Other Exemptions28
- [C][5][a] : Computer Professionals28
- [C][5][b] : Certain Medical Professionals30
- [C][5][c] : Commissioned Employees30
- [C][6] : Salary Basis Test31
- [C][7] : Extraterritorial Application of the Labor Code—The Sullivan v. Oracle Decision34
- § 1:2.3 : Independent Contractors and Temporary Workers35
- [A] : Independent Contractors37
- [B] : Temporary Workers and Joint Employment38
- [B][1] : Determining Employer Status39
- [B][2] : Wage-and-Hour Issues41
- § 1:2.4 : Interns42
- § 1:2.5 : Tip Pooling and California Labor Code Section 35143
- § 1:2.7 : Reimbursement of Expenses46
- [A] : California46
- [B] : New York47
- § 1:2.7 : Wage Deductions (New York)47
- § 1:2.8 : Hours Worked49
- [A] : “Hours Worked” Defined49
- [B] : Meal Breaks49
- [B][1] : FLSA49
- [B][2] : California49
- [B][3] : New York54
- [C] : On-Call and Waiting Time Under the FLSA55
- [D] : “De Minimis” Activities55
- [E] : Travel Time58
- § 1:2.9 : Calculating Overtime Premiums: Determining the Regular Rate61
- [A] : Premium Pay62
- [B] : Per Diem62
- [C] : Sick Leave Buy-Backs62
- [D] : “Blended” Pay Rates62
- [E] : California Regular Rate63
- [F] : Firefighters’ Overtime Rate63
- § 1:2.10 : Implementing “Flextime” Schedules64
- § 1:2.11 : Workweek Designation65
- § 1:2.12 : Employee Notice65
- [A] : California65
- [B] : New York66
- § 1:2.13 : Fluctuating Workweeks68
- [A] : The FWW Method of Calculating Overtime68
- [B] : Preconditions on Using the FWW Method69
- [C] : Using the FWW Method to Calculate Damages in Misclassification Cases70
- § 1:2.14 : Commissions/Bonuses/Incentive Compensation Plans72
- [A] : California72
- [B] : New York75
- § 1:2.15 : Individual Liability76
- [A] : FLSA76
- [B] : California77
- § 1:2.16 : Spread-of-Hours Pay (New York)78
- § 1:2.17 : Payment of Final Wages78
- [A] : New York78
- [B] : California78
- § 1:2.18 : Vacation Issues in California79
- § 1:3 : Wage and Hour Collective Class Action Process and Procedures80
- § 1:3.1 : Collective Actions Under the FLSA81
- [A] : Potential Members Must Expressly “Opt In” to the Class81
- [B] : Applicability of Requirements of Rule 23 to FLSA Collective Actions82
- [C] : Class Certification Under the FLSA84
- [C][1] : Overview84
- [C][2] : The Notice Stage: Plaintiffs Request Class Certification/Authorization to Send Notice to Putative Class Members; Courts Authorize Notice When Putative Members Are “Similarly Situated”84
- [C][3] : Stage Two—Defendant’s Motion to Decertify87
- [D] : FLSA Statute of Limitations88
- [E] : Waiver of FLSA Claims89
- [F] : Class Action Settlements90
- [G] : Settlement May Destroy Jurisdiction90
- [H] : Litigation Issues91
- [H][1] : Burdens of Proof91
- [H][2] : Interaction of State and Federal Actions—Hybrid Actions92
- [I] : Rule 68—Offers of Judgment93
- § 1:3.2 : California Class Actions94
- [A] : Governing Authority95
- [B] : Requirements for Establishment of California Class Actions95
- [C] : California Wage-and-Hour Class Actions95
- [D] : Procedural Issues in Class Action Lawsuits99
- [D][1] : Opt-Out Requirement99
- [D][2] : Class Certification’s Preclusive Effects99
- [D][3] : Statute of Limitations99
- [D][4] : Discovery100
- [D][5] : Timing of Motion to Deny Certification102
- [D][6] : Class Action Waiver in Arbitration Agreements103
- [D][7] : Settlement of California Class Actions105
- [D][8] : Release of Labor Code Claims107
- § 1:3.3 : Representative Actions Under Business and Professions Code Section 17200108
- [A] : Applicability to Wage-and-Hour Law108
- [B] : Equitable Relief Versus Damages109
- [C] : Statute of Limitations110
- [D] : Amendments to Section 17200111
- § 1:3.4 : California Labor Code Private Attorney General Act111
- § 1:3.5 : Shady Grove: Federal Preemption of State Law Limits on Certification113
- § 1:4 : Conclusion115
|
|
Chapter 2: |
OFCCP Developments |
|
|
- § 2:1 : Introduction118
- § 2:2 : OFCCP Enforcement Overview120
- § 2:2.1 : Administration Guidance and Focus122
- § 2:2.2 : New Active Case Enforcement Directive and Scheduling Letters122
- § 2:2.3 : A Newly Proposed Itemized Listing124
- [A] : New Item 8124
- [B] : Expanded Information Requests and Closer Scrutiny of Personnel Activity125
- [C] : Enhanced Compensation Review125
- [D] : Focus on Veterans126
- § 2:2.4 : Veterans Initiatives126
- § 2:2.5 : Disability Initiatives127
- § 2:2.6 : Increased Coordinated Enforcement Initiatives129
- [A] : Misclassification of Employees As Independent Contractors129
- [B] : EEOC/OFCCP Memorandum of Understanding Coordinating Enforcement for Discrimination129
- § 2:3 : Presidential Executive Orders130
- § 2:3.1 : Notification of Employee Rights Under Federal Labor Laws131
- § 2:3.2 : Economy in Government Contracting133
- § 2:3.3 : Nondisplacement of Workers Under Service Contracts134
- § 2:4 : Effects of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009135
- § 2:5 : Equal Pay Issues—OFCCP Compliance Standards and Voluntary Guidelines for Analyzing Compensation Systems136
- § 2:6 : OFCCP Case Law and Legislative Developments137
- § 2:6.1 : Expanded OFCCP Compensation Data Requests During Desk Audit Stage137
- § 2:6.2 : OFCCP Litigation of Pattern-or-Practice Cases—Utility of Statistics Alone138
- § 2:6.3 : Temporal Scope of Compliance Reviews During Desk Audit139
|
|
Chapter 3: |
Gender and Sexual Orientation Discrimination and Sexual Harassment |
|
|
- § 3:1 : Introduction143
- § 3:2 : Discrimination Based on Gender and Related Characteristics143
- § 3:2.1 : Gender Discrimination144
- [A] : Class Action Certification144
- [B] : Evidence147
- [C] : Reverse Bias Sex Discrimination149
- [D] : Damages Limitation150
- § 3:2.2 : Sexual Orientation and Gender Stereotyping151
- § 3:2.3 : Pregnancy Discrimination and Nursing Mother Laws154
- [A] : Pregnancy Discrimination Act154
- [B] : Protections for Nursing Mothers158
- § 3:2.4 : Physical and Testing Requirements161
- § 3:2.5 : Health Plan Coverage Issues164
- [A] : Prescription Contraceptive Coverage164
- § 3:3 : Equal Pay Act166
- § 3:3.1 : Establishing a Prima Facie Case167
- § 3:3.2 : Employer Defenses169
- § 3:3.3 : Statute of Limitations171
- § 3:3.4 : EEOC Guidance176
- § 3:3.5 : Legislation and Administrative Developments176
- § 3:4 : Sexual Harassment178
- § 3:4.1 : Discrimination Because of Sex178
- § 3:4.2 : Explicit Alteration of Fundamental Conditions of Employment: Tangible Employment Action181
- [A] : Case Law Defining “Tangible Employment Action”182
- [B] : EEOC Enforcement Guidance on “Tangible Employment Action”183
- § 3:4.3 : Constructive Alteration of Conditions of Employment or a Hostile Work Environment183
- [A] : Welcomeness183
- [B] : Cases Finding Severe or Pervasive Requirement Met186
- [C] : Cases Finding Severe or Pervasive Requirement Not Met188
- § 3:4.4 : Affirmative Defenses189
- [A] : Employer’s Duty to Exercise Reasonable Care to Prevent Harassing Behavior190
- [B] : Employer’s Duty to Exercise Reasonable Care to Correct Harassing Behavior Promptly194
- [B][1] : Employer Response Found to Be Inadequate194
- [B][2] : Employer Response Found to Be Appropriate196
- [B][3] : Employer Liable for Retaliation by Other Non-Supervisor197
- [B][4] : Acts of Non-Employees198
- [C] : Employee Unreasonably Failed to Take Advantage of Opportunities to Avoid Harm199
- [C][1] : Plaintiff’s Failure to Complain200
- [C][2] : Timeliness of Plaintiff’s Complaint201
- [D] : EEOC Enforcement Guidance on Employer Liability for Harassment by Supervisors203
- § 3:4.5 : Evidentiary Issues in Sex Harassment Cases: Effect of Statute of Limitations on Evidence of Acts Occurring Before Limitations Period203
- § 3:4.6 : Application of Legal Standards: Summary Judgment Versus Jury Trials207
- § 3:4.7 : Punitive Damages208
- § 3:4.8 : Principles of Vicarious Employer Liability and Concepts of Agency: When Is an Individual Considered a “Supervisor”?209
- [A] : EEOC Guidance210
- [B] : Representative Cases211
- § 3:4.9 : Individual Supervisor Liability213
- [A] : Federal Law213
- [B] : State Law213
- [B][1] : California213
- [B][2] : New York214
- § 3:4.10 : Other Procedural Issues215
- [A] : “Pattern-or-Practice” Cases215
- [B] : EEOC “Waiting Period”216
- § 3:4.11 : Theories Used by Accused Sexual Harassers Who Have Been Disciplined or Terminated218
- § 3:4.12 : Attorney Fees Where Plaintiff’s Lawsuit Is Frivolous, Unreasonable, or Without Foundation218
|
|
Chapter 4: |
Race, Religion, and National Origin Discrimination |
|
|
- § 4:1 : Race221
- § 4:1.1 : Subordinate Bias, “Cat’s Paw,” “Rubber Stamp” Theory223
- § 4:1.2 : “Me Too” Evidence227
- § 4:1.3 : Summary Judgment Test in “Mixed-Motive” Cases229
- § 4:1.4 : Section 1981 Claims232
- § 4:1.5 : “Class-of-One” Claims in Public Employment235
- § 4:1.6 : Adverse Employment Action236
- § 4:1.7 : Reverse Bias in Promotional Examinations239
- § 4:1.8 : Other Promotional Issues: Lists and Affirmative Action244
- § 4:1.9 : Tests and Selection Procedures—EEOC Guidance Fact Sheet249
- § 4:1.10 : “Associated with” Claims250
- § 4:1.11 : EEOC Procedural and Compliance Issues251
- § 4:1.12 : Insufficient Evidence of Race Discrimination/Bias258
- § 4:1.13 : Sufficient Evidence of Race Discrimination/Bias264
- § 4:1.14 : Title VII Class Action Issues268
- § 4:1.15 : Title VII Standing272
- § 4:2 : Religious Discrimination274
- § 4:3 : National Origin Discrimination286
|
|
Chapter 5: |
Age Discrimination |
|
|
- § 5:1 : Introduction296
- § 5:2 : Procedural Requirements298
- § 5:2.1 : A “Charge” with the EEOC298
- § 5:2.2 : Timeliness and Equitable Tolling300
- § 5:2.3 : ADEA Safe Harbor—Retiree Benefit Plans301
- § 5:3 : Who Is an Employer for Purposes of the ADEA?304
- § 5:4 : Who Is an Employee for Purposes of the ADEA?306
- § 5:4.1 : The Law Enforcement Exception307
- § 5:5 : Plaintiff’s Burden to Prove a Prima Facie Case308
- § 5:5.1 : Employer’s Legitimate Expectations310
- § 5:5.2 : Stray Remarks311
- § 5:5.3 : Similarly Situated312
- § 5:6 : Employer’s Legitimate Nondiscriminatory Business Reason313
- § 5:7 : Plaintiff’s Burden to Prove Employer’s Lawful Reason Is Pretext for Age Discrimination314
- § 5:7.1 : Insufficient Evidence of Pretext314
- § 5:7.2 : Sufficient Evidence of Pretext318
- § 5:8 : Retaliation Against Protected Activity321
- § 5:9 : Methods of Proof: Mixed Motives, Direct and Circumstantial, Pattern or Practice, and Disparate Treatment or Impact324
- § 5:9.1 : Mixed Motives324
- § 5:9.2 : Direct and Circumstantial Evidence327
- § 5:9.3 : Pattern or Practice329
- § 5:9.4 : Disparate-Impact Theory330
- § 5:9.5 : Other Methods of Proof332
- § 5:10 : Releases and Waivers334
- § 5:10.1 : The Requirements of the OWBPA334
- § 5:10.2 : Case Law Regarding OWBPA Releases336
- [A] : Ratification and Tender Back Under the OWBPA336
- [B] : Cure of the Defective Release337
- [C] : Invalid Waiver As a Separate Cause of Action338
- [D] : OWBPA Requirements Not Applied to Non-Age Claims339
- § 5:10.3 : EEOC Regulations Regarding OWBPA Releases339
- [A] : Wording of Waiver Agreements340
- [B] : Waiver of Future Rights341
- [C] : Consideration342
- [D] : Consultation342
- [E] : Time Periods342
- [F] : Informational Requirements343
- [F][1] : To Whom the Information Must Be Given344
- [F][2] : Mandatory Information344
- [G] : Waivers Settling Charges and Lawsuits346
- [H] : EEOC’s Enforcement Powers347
- [H][1] : Tender Back347
- [H][2] : Covenants Not to Challenge Waiver347
- [H][3] : Abrogation348
- [H][4] : Burden348
- § 5:11 : Other Issues348
- § 5:11.1 : Arbitration of ADEA Claims348
- § 5:11.2 : Remedies349
- § 5:11.4 : Harassment Based on Age351
|
|
Chapter 6: |
EEO Class Actions |
|
|
- § 6:1 : Introduction354
- § 6:2 : Recent Developments355
- § 6:3 : Litigating Class Action Certification361
- § 6:3.1 : Certification Elements of a Class Action362
- [A] : Numerosity363
- [B] : Commonality363
- [B][1] : Need for Reasonable Connection Between the Claims of the Named Plaintiffs and the Alleged Class and Within the Class363
- [B][1][a] : Commonality Based on Decentralized, Subjective Decision-Making and Dukes v. Wal-Mart364
- [B][2] : Commonality in Harassment Cases370
- [C] : Typicality371
- [D] : Adequacy of Representation372
- [D][1] : Adequacy of Counsel372
- [D][2] : Relation Between Class Representatives and Class374
- § 6:3.3 : Maintainability of the Class Action Suit—Fulfillment of Rule 23(b) Generally376
- [A] : Opting Out377
- [B] : Rule 23 Notice Amendments378
- § 6:3.4 : Fulfillment of Rule 23(b) in Employment Discrimination Class Actions379
- [A] : Certification Under Rule 23(b)(2) in Actions That Involve Compensatory and Punitive Damages379
- [B] : Intentional Discrimination Class Actions Under Rule 23(b)(3)381
- [C] : Hybrid Certification383
- [D] : WARN Act Cases384
- § 6:3.4 : Appellate Review of Class Certification Decisions385
- [A] : Interlocutory Review385
- [B] : Review After Named Plaintiff’s Claim Has Become Moot387
- [C] : Interlocutory Appeal of Conditional FLSA Collective Actions388
- § 6:3.5 : Other Class Action Issues388
- § 6:4 : Disparate-Treatment and Disparate-Impact Cases390
- § 6:4.1 : Disparate-Treatment Class Actions390
- § 6:4.2 : Disparate-Impact Class Actions393
- § 6:4.3 : Special Problems in Multi-Facility Cases394
- § 6:4.4 : The Ricci v. DeStefano Legacy: A Strong Basis in Evidence Requirement and the Potential Disparate Impact Problem395
- § 6:4.5 : The New York Firefighters’ Case402
- § 6:5 : Punitive Damages in Disparate-Treatment Pattern-or-Practice Cases404
- § 6:6 : Opt-In Class Actions406
- § 6:7 : Class Action Fairness Act of 2005408
- § 6:7.1 : The Purpose and Intent of the Law409
- § 6:7.2 : Basis for Federal Court Jurisdiction409
- § 6:7.3 : What Is a Covered Class Action?413
- § 6:7.4 : Changes to Removal Rules414
- § 6:7.5 : “Mass Action”414
- § 6:7.6 : “Coupon” Settlements and Attorney Fees415
- § 6:7.7 : Geographic Discrimination415
- § 6:8 : EEOC Litigation416
- § 6:8.1 : Pursuing Pattern-or-Practice Claims Under Section 706 of Title VII416
- § 6:8.2 : Statutes of Limitation Under Section 707420
- § 6:8.3 : Rule 23’s Inapplicability to Pattern-or-Practice Claims422
- § 6:8.4 : Attorney-Client Privilege424
- § 6:9 : Statistical Evidence425
- § 6:9.1 : Need for Appropriate, Probative Statistical Comparisons427
- § 6:9.2 : Regression Analyses432
- § 6:9.3 : Statistical Significance435
- § 6:9.4 : Attacking Plaintiffs’ Statistics437
- § 6:9.5 : Summary439
- § 6:10 : Settlement of Class Actions440
- § 6:10.1 : Rule 23 Amendments440
- § 6:10.2 : Class Certification for Settlement441
- [A] : Protecting Interests of Absent Class Members443
- [B] : Attorney Fees444
|
|
Chapter 7: |
Americans with Disabilities Act |
|
|
- § 7:1 : Introduction449
- § 7:2 : The EEOC Experience to Date450
- § 7:3 : Basic Issues Under the ADA452
- § 7:3.1 : EEOC Regulations Implementing the ADAAA452
- [A] : Revisions to “actual disability” Prong452
- [B] : Revisions to “record of” Prong454
- [C] : Revisions to “regarded as” Prong454
- § 7:3.2 : Who Is a “Qualified Individual”?455
- § 7:3.3 : Who Is Disabled?457
- [A] : Physical or Mental Impairment458
- [B] : Temporary or Intermittent, Episodic Impairments463
- [C] : Substantial Limitation466
- [D] : Major Life Activities470
- [D][1] : Scope of Major Life Activity471
- [D][2] : Other Cases—Major Life Activity Recognized471
- [D][3] : Other Cases—Major Life Activity Not Recognized472
- [E] : Perceived Impairments473
- [F] : Association with a Disabled Person474
- [G] : Exclusions from the Definition of Disability475
- [G][1] : Excluded Matters475
- [G][2] : Drugs and Alcohol—Specific Provisions475
- § 7:3.4 : Qualification478
- [A] : Essential Functions of the Job478
- [B] : Estoppel from Claiming Ability to Perform Essential Job Functions481
- [C] : Direct Threat484
- [D] : Causation484
- § 7:3.5 : Ministerial Exception486
- § 7:4 : The Duty to Provide Reasonable Accommodation487
- § 7:4.1 : EEOC Reasonable Accommodation Enforcement Guidance488
- § 7:4.2 : Statutory and Regulatory Examples of Reasonable Accommodation489
- § 7:4.3 : 2005 Department of Labor Survey490
- § 7:4.4 : When Is an Employer Obligated to Make a Reasonable Accommodation?491
- § 7:4.5 : Identifying Reasonable Accommodations492
- § 7:5 : Judicial Interpretation of Reasonable Accommodation495
- § 7:5.1 : Accommodation for Applicants495
- § 7:5.2 : Job Restructuring and Reallocation of Job Duties496
- § 7:5.3 : Light Duty497
- § 7:5.4 : Transfer or Reassignment to a Vacant Position498
- [A] : Accommodation Required498
- [B] : Accommodation Not Required Where Employee Fails to Identify Vacant Position for Which He or She Is Qualified500
- [C] : Transfer to a New Position Is Accommodation of Last Resort503
- § 7:5.5 : Modification of Work Schedule/Attendance Requirement503
- [A] : Accommodation Required503
- [B] : Accommodation Not Required506
- § 7:5.6 : Work at Home/Work Outside the Office509
- § 7:5.7 : Transportation to and from Work510
- § 7:5.8 : Requests for Leave510
- § 7:5.9 : Modifying No-Fault Attendance Policies As a Reasonable Accommodation511
- § 7:5.10 : Duty to Provide Reasonable Accommodation for Perceived Disability511
- § 7:6 : Disability Harassment511
- § 7:7 : Job Application Procedures: Pre- and Post-Employment Inquiries512
- § 7:7.1 : Pre-Employment Inquiries512
- § 7:7.2 : Post-Employment Inquiries516
- § 7:7.3 : Qualification Standards518
- § 7:7.4 : Medical Examinations and Safeguarding Medical Information522
- [A] : What Is a Medical Examination?523
- [B] : What Constitutes a Conditional Job Offer After Which a Medical Examination May Be Required?526
- § 7:7.5 : Other Disability-Related Inquiries and Medical Examinations of Employees526
- § 7:8 : Employer Defenses to Requests for Reasonable Accommodation527
- § 7:8.1 : Undue Hardship527
- § 7:8.2 : Direct Threat to Health or Safety of Individual or Others528
- § 7:8.3 : Limitation Period531
- § 7:9 : The Application of the ADA to Employers’ Health Insurance Plans533
- § 7:10 : Relief Available Under the ADA534
- § 7:11 : Conclusion540
|
|
Chapter 8: |
Employee Privacy Law |
|
|
- § 8:1 : Introduction547
- § 8:2 : Pre-Employment Inquiries548
- § 8:2.1 : A Framework for the Interview Process548
- § 8:2.2 : Prohibited Subjects550
- [A] : Name/Marital Status550
- [B] : Age/Birthdate550
- [C] : Health and Physical Condition551
- [D] : AIDS552
- [E] : Arrest Records553
- [F] : Convictions554
- [G] : National Origin and Citizenship555
- [H] : Religion555
- [I] : Sex and Marital Status555
- [J] : Past Drug Use556
- [K] : Facially Neutral Criteria556
- § 8:2.3 : Using the Internet to Research Applicant’s Background557
- § 8:2.4 : Best Practices for the Interview Process558
- [A] : Brief the Recruiters and Interviewers558
- [B] : Adopt a Checklist558
- [C] : Allocate Interview Responsibility558
- [D] : Provide Examples of Permissible Questions559
- [E] : Use Evaluation Forms559
- [F] : Guidelines Based on ADA Provisions559
- § 8:3 : The Employer’s Need to Know Versus the Employee’s Right to Privacy—The Bases of the Right to Privacy560
- § 8:3.1 : Constitutional560
- [A] : Federal560
- [A][1] : Searches by Public Employers560
- [A][2] : Investigations of Applicants and Employees by Public Employers563
- [B] : New York564
- [C] : California564
- [C][1] : Hill v. NCAA565
- [C][2] : Analyzing Privacy Interests in the Employment Context567
- [C][3] : Hill’s Progeny568
- § 8:3.2 : Statutory572
- [A] : Federal572
- [A][1] : Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986572
- [B] : States574
- [B][1] : New York574
- [B][2] : California576
- § 8:3.3 : Common-Law Privacy Protections for Private Employees578
- [A] : California579
- [B] : New York580
- § 8:3.4 : Application of Privacy Laws to “New Technology”580
- [A] : Email580
- [B] : Blogs and Social Networks584
- [C] : GPS Tracking587
- § 8:3.5 : Reasons to Monitor Employees’ Use of Electronic Media589
- § 8:3.6 : Third-Party Discovery of Employee Information590
- § 8:3.7 : NLRA Implications for Employee Privacy Policies591
- § 8:3.8 : Tort Liability592
- [A] : Claims Not Barred by California’s Workers’ Compensation Law592
- § 8:3.9 : Application of the Right to Privacy593
- [A] : Whether an Employee’s Expectation of Privacy Is Reasonable593
- [B] : Analyzing the Employer’s and the Employee’s Competing Interests596
- [B][1] : Federal Cases596
- [B][2] : New York598
- [B][3] : California598
- § 8:3.10 : Practical Guidelines for Employee Searches601
- § 8:4 : Substance Abuse602
- § 8:4.1 : In General602
- § 8:4.2 : Determining the Appropriate Type of Drug and Alcohol Policy603
- [A] : Determine the Extent and Risk of Drug and Alcohol Use by Employees603
- [B] : Determine Whether Federal or State Law Requires or Prohibits Any Particular Drug or Alcohol Policy in Your Workplace604
- [B][1] : Legal Requirements for Federal Contractors and Grantees604
- [B][1][a] : The Drug-Free Work Place Act604
- [B][1][b] : Defense, Transportation, and Nuclear Regulatory Commission Regulations605
- [B][2] : Legal Restrictions on Drug Testing605
- [B][2][a] : U.S. Supreme Court Cases606
- [B][2][b] : Lessons of the Customs and Railway Cases607
- [B][2][c] : Random Drug Testing Addressed by U.S. Supreme Court608
- [B][2][d] : California Cases609
- [B][2][e] : California and Ninth Circuit Decisions Regarding the Constitutionality of Drug Tests610
- [B][3] : Civil Rights Statutes611
- [B][4] : Potential Liability Under Common-Law Tort611
- [B][4][a] : Defamation and Invasion of Privacy612
- [B][4][b] : Negligent Hiring and/or Retention of Employees612
- [B][4][c] : False Imprisonment613
- [B][4][d] : False Arrest613
- § 8:4.3 : Consider Adopting a Strong Drug or Alcohol Policy Before Requiring Testing613
- [A] : Any Drug and Alcohol Policy Should Be Communicated in Writing614
- [B] : Considering a Rehabilitative Option615
- [C] : A Supervisor’s Role Should Be Determined and Communicated615
- [D] : Consider Other Preventive Measures and Investigative Techniques617
- [E] : Consider Negative Implications Before Adopting a Drug-Testing Program618
- § 8:4.4 : Developing a Drug-Testing Policy619
- § 8:4.5 : Implementing Drug-Testing Policies622
- § 8:5 : Investigations and Testing on Prospective and Current Employees622
- § 8:5.1 : Conducting Background Investigations on Prospective and Current Employees Through a Consumer Reporting Agency622
- [A] : Initial Issues to Address Before Conducting Background Investigations625
- [A][1] : Determining the Applicants on Whom to Perform Background Checks625
- [A][2] : Information to Be Obtained from Background Checks626
- [A][3] : Who Should Perform Background Checks626
- [A][4] : Information Employers Should Obtain from Applicants to Perform Background Checks626
- [B] : The Fair Credit Reporting Act and Its Amendments627
- [B][1] : What Is a “Consumer Report”?627
- [B][2] : What Is a CRA?628
- [B][3] : Inquiries Should Be Job-Related628
- [B][4] : Obsolete Information628
- [B][5] : Penalties for Noncompliance628
- [C] : Supplemental California Laws629
- [C][1] : California’s Consumer Credit Reporting Agencies Act629
- [C][2] : California’s Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act629
- [D] : Supplemental New York Laws630
- [E] : Summary of Steps an Employer Should Take When Requesting Consumer Reports631
- [E][1] : Provide Initial Notice and Obtain Written Authorization631
- [E][1][a] : Additional Initial Disclosure Requirements for Consumer Credit Reports Under the CCRAA631
- [E][1][b] : Additional Requirements for Investigative Consumer Reports631
- [E][2] : Provide Certification of Compliance to the CRA633
- [E][2][a] : Additional Certification That an Employer Should Make to the CRA When Requesting an Investigative Consumer Report633
- [E][3] : Provide the Consumer with Information634
- [E][4] : Provide Adverse Action Notice After Adverse Employment Action Has Been Taken634
- [E][5] : Under the ICRAA, Investigative Information May Be Disclosed in All Cases635
- [F] : Frequently Asked Questions635
- [F][1] : If a Computer Database Is Used to Obtain Information, Should the Employer Comply with the FCRA?635
- [F][2] : Can the Initial Disclosure Include an Authorizing Signature Line?636
- [F][3] : Do Employers Really Have to Provide the Consumer with the Same Information Twice?636
- [F][4] : What If the Employer Hires an Intermediary to Compile Information from Several Consumer Reporting Agencies?636
- [F][5] : How Long Should an Employer Wait Between Giving the Pre-Adverse Action Disclosure and the Adverse Action Notice?637
- [G] : Practical Applications637
- [H] : Suggestions for Hiring and Conducting Background Checks639
- § 8:5.2 : Compiling Background Information Without Utilizing the Services of a CRS and Conducting Internal Investigations639
- [A] : When an Employer Uses an Outside Entity for an Internal Investigation639
- [B] : When an Employer Does Not Use an Outside Entity to Compile Investigative Information or Conduct an Investigation641
- [B][1] : Investigative Consumer Reports That an Employer Compiles in Connection with Its Application Process642
- [B][1][a] : References642
- [B][1][b] : Prior Employers642
- [B][2] : Internal Investigations That an Employer Conducts in Response to an Allegation or Suspicion of Employee Misconduct or Wrongdoing643
- [B][2][a] : Attorney-Client Privilege/Attorney Work Product643
- § 8:5.3 : Polygraph Examinations645
- [A] : In General645
- [B] : Record Keeping647
- [C] : Rights of the Examinee647
- [D] : Practical Guidelines for Polygraph Testing648
- § 8:5.4 : Honesty Testing649
- [A] : In General649
- [B] : Practical Advice for Employers Utilizing Honesty Tests649
- § 8:5.5 : Tests of Skills and Abilities650
- § 8:5.6 : Psychological and Psychiatric Testing650
- § 8:5.7 : Fingerprints and Photographs651
- § 8:5.8 : Genetic Testing652
|
|
Chapter 9: |
Guarding Trade Secrets |
|
|
- § 9:1 : Introduction657
- § 9:2 : What Is a Trade Secret?658
- § 9:2.1 : Uniform Trade Secrets Act and the California Definition658
- [A] : Secrecy661
- [A][1] : Publicly Known Through Internet Disclosure662
- [B] : Reasonable Efforts to Preserve Secrecy664
- [B][1] : Require That Employees (and Third Parties) Who Are Given Access to Trade Secrets Sign Confidentiality Agreements664
- [B][2] : Alert Employees (and Third Parties) with Access to Trade Secrets Regarding Their Confidential Nature665
- [B][3] : Limit Access to Only Those Employees (and Third Parties) Who “Need to Know” Trade Secrets to Perform Their Jobs665
- [B][4] : Avoid Public Disclosure of Trade Secret Information Through Display, Publication, Advertising, Etc.665
- [C] : Value Derived from Secrecy666
- § 9:2.2 : Restatement of Torts and the New York Definition666
- § 9:2.3 : Trade Secret Protection Checklist and the New York Definition669
- § 9:3 : Keeping Employees from Competing or Working for Competitors upon Their Departure671
- § 9:3.1 : Background671
- § 9:3.2 : In Most States, Covenants Not to Compete Will Be Enforced If They Are Necessary to Protect a Legitimate Interest of the Employer673
- [A] : What Is a “Legitimate Employer Interest”?676
- [A][1] : Trade Secrets As a “Legitimate Employer Interest”677
- [A][2] : Customer Lists As a “Legitimate Employer Interest”677
- [A][3] : Customer Solicitation As a “Legitimate Employer Interest”678
- [A][4] : An Employee’s Unique Services As a “Legitimate Employer Interest”9679
- [B] : Reasonableness Standard for Enforcement of Covenants Not to Compete681
- [C] : Other Factors Affecting the Reasonableness of Covenants Not to Compete683
- § 9:3.3 : Garden Leave and Notice Provisions684
- § 9:3.4 : The Employee Choice Doctrine684
- § 9:3.5 : Under California Law, Employee Covenants Not to Compete upon Termination of Employment Are Void686
- [A] : The California Rule and Its Application686
- [A][1] : The Policy Behind the California Rule687
- [A][2] : Choice-of-Law Provisions Cannot Be Used to Avoid the California Rule687
- [A][3] : California Courts Will Not Rewrite an Overly Broad Non-Compete Provision to Make It Valid690
- [B] : California Courts May Enforce Certain Types of Non-Compete Clauses That Limit, But Do Not Prohibit, Competition691
- [B][1] : Covenants by Employees Not to Use or Disclose Their Employers’ Trade Secrets Are Enforceable in California691
- [B][2] : Prohibition Against a Limited Subset of Activities692
- [B][3] : The Trade Secrets Exception693
- [B][4] : Other Statutory Exceptions Allowing Restraints on Competition695
- [C] : Enforcement of Non-Solicitation Clauses696
- [C][1] : What Is “Solicitation”?696
- [C][2] : Customer Solicitation697
- [C][3] : Competitor Employee Raiding Absent a Non-Solicitation Clause699
- [C][4] : Competitor Employee Raiding in Light of a Non-Solicitation Clause700
- § 9:4 : Preventing Departing Employees from Using or Disclosing Trade Secrets703
- § 9:4.1 : Background703
- § 9:4.2 : Sources of Protection for Employers703
- [A] : Civil Remedies for Trade Secret Misappropriation703
- [A][1] : Basis for Liability703
- [A][2] : Available Remedies705
- [A][3] : Limitations Periods707
- [A][4] : Risks Associated with Civil Discovery708
- [B] : The Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine May Be Used to Prevent “Threatened” Misappropriation of Trade Secrets709
- [B][1] : New York and Most Other States Have Adopted the Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine710
- [B][2] : California Has Rejected the Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine714
- [C] : Other Potential Remedies Available to the Employer715
- [C][1] : Common-Law Duty of Loyalty and Law of Unfair Competition715
- [C][2] : Tortious Interference with Contractual Relations717
- [C][3] : Computer Fraud and Abuse Act718
- [C][4] : Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act718
- [D] : Effect of Trade Secret Preemption719
- [E] : Criminal Statutes720
- [E][1] : Federal Statutes720
- [E][2] : California Statutes722
- [E][3] : New York Statutes722
- § 9:5 : Protection of Trade Secrets Abroad723
- § 9:5.1 : Trade Secrets Under German Law723
- [A] : The Protection of Trade Secrets Under Labor Law723
- [A][1] : Secrecy Obligations of Employees725
- [A][1][a] : Protection of Trade Secrets During Employment725
- [A][1][b] : Protection of Trade Secrets After Employment726
- [B] : The Protection of Trade Secrets Under the Act Against Unfair Competition727
- [C] : The Protection of Trade Secrets Under the German Criminal Code728
- [D] : Violations of Secrecy Obligations During Employment728
- [D][1] : Measures of Labor Law728
- [D][2] : Further Legal Actions729
- [E] : Violations of Secrecy Obligations After the End of Employment731
- [F] : Cross-Border Protection of Trade Secrets732
- [G] : Recommendations732
- § 9:5.2 : Trade Secrets Under British Law733
- [A] : Choice of Law733
- [B] : The Duarte Danger733
- [C] : Samengo-Turner734
- [D] : European Safeguards736
- [E] : Lawful Protections and Public Policy Considerations in the United Kingdom737
- [E][1] : Implied Duties737
- [E][1][a] : Fiduciary Duties737
- [E][1][b] : Duty of Fidelity738
- [E][1][c] : Duty of Confidentiality739
- [E][2] : Express Duties740
- [E][2][a] : Confidentiality740
- [E][2][b] : Intellectual Property741
- [E][2][c] : Duty Not to Compete During Employment741
- [E][2][d] : Post-Termination Restrictive Covenants742
- [E][3] : Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants742
- [E][3][a] : Public Policy742
- [E][3][b] : Reasonableness742
- [E][3][c] : Legitimate Interests742
- [E][3][c][i] : Trade Connections or Goodwill743
- [E][3][c][ii] : Trade Secrets and Confidential Information743
- [E][3][c][iii] : The Stability of the Workforce, in Terms of Retention of Employees743
- [E][3][d] : Scope743
- [E][3][d][i] : Length744
- [E][3][d][ii] : Area744
- [E][3][d][iii] : Considerations745
- [E][3][d][iv] : Group Companies745
- [E][3][d][v] : Tailoring to Circumstances745
- [E][3][e] : Severability746
- [E][4] : Examples of Post-Termination Restrictive Covenants747
- [E][4][a] : Post-Termination Non-Compete747
- [E][4][b] : Non-Solicitation of Customers/Clients748
- [E][4][c] : Non-Dealing with Customers/Clients750
- [E][4][d] : Non-Poaching and/or Engagement of Employees750
- [F] : Investigation and Enforcement751
- [F][1] : Vigilance and Speed751
- [F][2] : Investigation752
- [F][2][a] : Disciplinary/Dismissal752
- [F][2][b] : Gathering Evidence752
- [F][2][c] : International Data Transfer753
- [F][2][d] : Computer Forensics754
- [F][2][e] : Identify the Team754
- [F][3] : Remedies754
- [F][3][a] : Injunctions754
- [F][3][b] : Damages755
- [F][3][c] : Account of Profits755
- [F][3][d] : Evidential Orders755
- [F][3][e] : Actions Against Third Parties755
- [F][3][f] : Costs and Cross-Undertakings756
- [G] : Summary756
- § 9:5.3 : Trade Secret Protection in China757
- [A] : Definition of Trade Secret and Civil Law Protection761
- [B] : Administrative Enforcement and Criminal Proceedings765
- [C] : Trade Secret Protection Under Labor Law and Labor Contract Law766
- [C][1] : Confidentiality Agreements766
- [C][2] : Non-Compete Agreements767
- [C][3] : Non-Solicitation Agreements769
- [D] : Evidence Collection and Employee Privacy Concerns770
- [D][1] : “Evidence Preservation”771
- [D][2] : Employee Privacy; Employee Computer Usage/Email771
- [E] : Governing Law and Jurisdictional Issues773
- [F] : Recommendations774
- § 9:6 : A Primer on Strategy: Before and After an Employee Leaves777
- § 9:6.1 : Establishing and Maintaining Secrecy777
- [A] : Confidentiality Agreements778
- [B] : Non-Compete, Non-Solicitation, and Non-Disclosure Provisions; Severability Clause778
- [C] : Confidentiality Alerts/Reminders780
- [D] : Limited Access780
- [E] : Avoiding Public Disclosure780
- § 9:6.2 : What to Do When an Employee Leaves781
- [A] : Exit Interview781
- [B] : Search of Departing Employee’s Workspace/Computer783
- [C] : Forensic Analysis of Employee’s Computer783
- [D] : Follow-Up Letters787
- [E] : Restrictive Covenants788
- [F] : Risk Monitoring789
|
|
Chapter 10: |
Reductions in Force; And Appendices 10A-10I |
|
|
- § 10:1 : Introduction794
- § 10:2 : Discrimination and Common-Law Causes of Action795
- § 10:2.1 : Potential Discrimination Claims795
- [A] : In General795
- [B] : Disparate Treatment Theory795
- [C] : Disparate Impact Theory796
- § 10:2.2 : Common-Law Claims800
- § 10:2.3 : Evidentiary Considerations801
- [A] : Impermissible Statements801
- [B] : Reorganized Job Responsibilities802
- [C] : Statistics803
- [D] : Competence and Performance804
- [E] : Cost Factor804
- [F] : “Me Too” Evidence805
- § 10:2.4 : Potential Liability and Damages807
- § 10:3 : Alternatives to a Reduction in Force808
- § 10:3.1 : Voluntary Separation Programs (VSPs)808
- [A] : Typical Features of VSPs809
- [A][1] : Severance Benefits809
- [A][2] : Eligibility809
- [A][3] : “Window Periods”810
- [B] : Are Incentives Permissible?810
- [C] : VSPs and Discrimination812
- [D] : Voluntariness812
- § 10:3.2 : Early Retirement Programs (ERPs)814
- [A] : Legal Considerations815
- [B] : Age As a Criterion of Plan Eligibility and Benefits815
- [C] : Voluntariness815
- § 10:3.3 : Potential ERISA Liability for Misrepresentation of or Failure to Disclose Future Enhanced Retirement Packages or Benefits816
- § 10:4 : Planning for a Reduction in Force817
- § 10:4.1 : Establish Corporate Justification for RIF817
- § 10:4.2 : Practical Considerations for Implementing a Reduction in Force818
- [A] : Workforce Analysis and Demographics819
- [B] : Management Training820
- [C] : Communication with Employees821
- [D] : Selection of Employees for Retention821
- [D][1] : Generally821
- [D][2] : Jobs and Their Relative Value822
- [D][3] : Evaluation and Relative Ranking of Employees822
- [D][3][a] : Performance Evaluations Generally822
- [D][3][b] : Evaluation Criteria824
- [D][3][c] : Existing Versus New Evaluations825
- [D][3][d] : Comparative Employee Ranking825
- [E] : Oversight826
- [E][1] : Workforce Analysis826
- [E][2] : Evaluation of Jobs/Employees828
- [E][3] : Thorough Review of Individual Problems828
- [E][4] : Exit Interview828
- [F] : Post-RIF Considerations829
- § 10:4.3 : Obtaining Releases829
- § 10:4.4 : Obtaining ADEA Releases831
- [A] : General Waiver Requirements Under the OWBPA831
- [B] : “Knowing and Voluntary” Requirement832
- [C] : Wording of Waiver Agreement833
- [D] : Specific Referral to Rights or Claims834
- [E] : Waiver of Future Rights834
- [F] : Consideration834
- [G] : Consultation with Attorney835
- [H] : Time Periods835
- [H][1] : Time to Consider Agreement835
- [H][2] : Time to Revoke Release836
- [I] : Special Informational Requirements for Group Termination “Programs”837
- [I][1] : Exit Incentive or Other Employment Termination Programs837
- [I][2] : Organizational Unit Defined838
- [I][3] : Eligibility Factors841
- [I][4] : Presentation of Information842
- [I][4][a] : Categorization of Employees842
- [I][4][b] : Scope of Disclosure843
- [J] : Other Requirements Under OWBPA844
- [J][1] : Waivers Settling Charges or Lawsuits844
- [J][2] : Burden of Proof844
- [J][3] : EEOC’s Enforcement Power844
- [K] : EEOC Regulations on ADEA Waivers845
- [K][1] : No Ratification of Waiver by Employee’s Retention of Severance Payments845
- [K][2] : “Tender Back”846
- [K][3] : Restitution/Set-Off846
- [K][4] : Covenants Not to Challenge Waiver847
- [K][5] : Abrogation847
- [K][6] : Cure of the Defective Release848
- [K][7] : Invalid Waiver As a Separate Cause of Action849
- [K][8] : Effect of Invalid Waiver on Timeliness of ADEA Suit850
- [L] : OWBPA Requirements Not Applied to Non-Age Claims851
- [M] : Admissibility of Unsigned Agreement in ADEA Action851
- § 10:5 : Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act852
- § 10:5.1 : Who Must Give Notice853
- § 10:5.2 : Mass Layoffs and Plant Closings Under WARN854
- [A] : “Plant Closing” Defined854
- [B] : “Mass Layoff” Defined854
- [C] : “Reduction in Force” Defined855
- [D] : “Single Site of Employment” Defined856
- [E] : “Part-Time Employee” Defined857
- [F] : “Employment Loss” Defined857
- [G] : Losses Must Be Aggregated862
- [H] : Temporary or Delayed Layoff862
- [I] : Temporary Hire Exception863
- [J] : Strike or Lockout Exception863
- § 10:5.3 : To Whom Notice Must Be Given and What a Valid Notice Must Include864
- [A] : To Whom Notice Must Be Given864
- [B] : What a Valid Notice Must Include864
- § 10:5.4 : When Less Than Sixty Days’ Notice Can Be Given865
- [A] : Faltering Company Exception865
- [B] : Unforeseeable Circumstances Exception866
- [C] : Act of Nature Exception867
- § 10:5.5 : WARN and Bankruptcy867
- § 10:5.6 : Waiver of WARN Claims867
- § 10:5.7 : Penalties for Violating WARN868
- [A] : Penalties868
- [B] : Payments in Lieu of Notice869
- § 10:5.8 : WARN Class Actions869
- § 10:5.9 : Right to Jury Trial870
- § 10:5.10 : California WARN Act870
- [A] : Labor Code Section 1400 et seq., Applies to More Employers Than WARN Covers871
- [B] : Labor Code Section 1400 et seq., Appears to Cover Parent Companies871
- [C] : Absent Extraordinary Circumstances, Covered Employers Must Provide Notice of Layoffs, Relocations or Terminations, or Face Significant Damages and Stiff Penalties872
- § 10:5.11 : New Jersey WARN Act872
- [A] : Who Must Give Notice872
- [B] : Definition of Employment Loss873
- [C] : To Whom Notice Must Be Given873
- [D] : What a Valid Notice Must Include873
- [E] : Penalties874
- [F] : Establishment of a Response Team874
- § 10:5.12 : New York WARN Act874
- § 10:6 : Conclusion879
- Appendix 10A : Sample Notices of Plant Closure881
- Appendix 10B : Sample Notices of Mass Layoff883
- Appendix 10C : Sample Notice to State Dislocated Worker Unit and Local Government885
- Appendix 10D : Sample Corporate Policy Statement887
- Appendix 10E : Sample Reorganization Guidelines for Management889
- Appendix 10F : Sample Schedule of Reorganization Activities891
- Appendix 10G : Considerations for Conducting Termination Session893
- Appendix 10H : Sample Presentation of Statistical Information895
- Appendix 10I : Confidential Oversight Analysis897
|
|
Chapter 11: |
Whistleblowing and Other Retaliation Claims; And Appendices 11A-11C |
|
|
- § 11:1 : Introduction901
- § 11:2 : An Overview of Retaliation Under the EEO Laws905
- § 11:2.1 : The Retaliation Analysis907
- § 11:2.2 : The Prima Facie Case909
- [A] : Element 1: Protected Activity909
- [A][1] : The Opposition Clause912
- [A][1][a] : Examples of Protected Opposition Activity913
- [A][1][b] : Examples of Unprotected Opposition Activity917
- [A][1][c] : Reasonable and Non-Disruptive Requirement919
- [A][1][c][i] : Examples of Reasonable and Non-Disruptive Protests920
- [A][1][c][ii] : Examples of Unreasonable or Disruptive Protests921
- [A][1][d] : Reasonable, Good-Faith Belief Requirement922
- [A][2] : The Participation Clause924
- [A][2][a] : Participation in Litigation Process924
- [A][2][a][i] : Examples of Protected Participation Activity924
- [A][2][a][ii] : Examples of Non-Protected Participation Activity926
- [A][2][a][iii] : Miscellaneous “Participation Clause” Decisions928
- [A][2][b] : Lying During an Investigation928
- [B] : Element 2: Adverse Employment Action929
- [B][1] : Standard for Evaluating Whether an Employer’s Action Is Retaliatory931
- [B][1][a] : Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White931
- [B][1][b] : Cases Interpreting Burlington934
- [B][2] : Retaliation Based on Use of Judicial Process942
- [B][3] : Third-Party Retaliation946
- [B][3][a] : Retaliation Against “Closely Related” Individuals and Associational Retaliation946
- [B][3][b] : Retaliation by Different Entities949
- [C] : Element 3: Proof of Causal Connection950
- [C][1] : Direct Evidence of Retaliation; the Mixed-Motive Analysis950
- [C][2] : Circumstantial Evidence of Retaliation952
- [C][2][a] : Proving Causation with Circumstantial Evidence of Retaliation954
- [C][2][b] : Temporal Proximity954
- [C][2][b][i] : Cases Holding Inference of Causation Exists955
- [C][2][b][ii] : Cases Holding Inference of Causation Does Not Exist956
- [C][3] : Retaliatory Action Imputable to Employer958
- [C][3][a] : “Cat’s Paw” Theory of Liability959
- [C][3][b] : Retaliatory Harassment964
- [C][3][b][i] : Retaliatory Acts Will Be Imputed to Employer Where Employer Orchestrated Harassment965
- [C][3][b][ii] : Retaliatory Acts Will Be Imputed to Employer Where Employer Orchestrated Harassment, Knew About Harassment, or Failed to Stop It965
- [C][4] : Prior Criticism of Performance969
- § 11:2.3 : Rebutting the Prima Facie Case—Legitimate Business Reasons and the Employer’s Lack of Retaliatory Intent972
- § 11:2.4 : Pretext975
- § 11:2.5 : U.S. Supreme Court Authority977
- § 11:3 : Common-Law Claims and the Beginning of Retaliation Law980
- § 11:3.1 : Wrongful Termination in Violation of Public Policy980
- [A] : Internal Whistleblowing982
- [A][1] : Internal Reports Implicating Public Interest982
- [A][2] : Internal Reports of Misconduct That Do Not Inure to Public Benefit983
- [A][3] : Other Limits Imposed by the Court984
- [B] : External Whistleblowing984
- [C] : General Releases Overcome Public Policy Exception985
- § 11:3.2 : Breach of Implied Contract986
- [A] : New York986
- [B] : California986
- [C] : Weiner Exception: Employer Handbooks, Manuals, Codes of Conduct988
- [D] : Implied Contract and Whistleblowing Policies990
- § 11:3.3 : Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies993
- § 11:4 : The Whistleblower Protection Act994
- § 11:5 : First Amendment Retaliation Claims996
- § 11:6 : Title IX Retaliation1010
- § 11:7 : Sarbanes-Oxley and Whistleblower Law1011
- § 11:7.1 : Recent Amendments to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act1012
- § 11:7.2 : Recent Case Law Developments1013
- § 11:8 : American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 20091017
- § 11:9 : Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 20101018
- § 11:9.1 : Dodd-Frank Act Whistleblower Incentives1019
- § 11:9.2 : Dodd-Frank Whistleblower Protections1020
- § 11:9.3 : New Consumer Financial Whistleblower Protections1026
- Appendix 11A : EEOC Checklist of Relevant Questions for Investigating Complaints of Retaliation1029
- Appendix 11B : Federal Whistleblower Statutes1031
- Appendix 11C : State Whistleblower Statutes1045
|
|
Chapter 12: |
Employee Blogging and Social Media |
|
|
- § 12:1 : Introduction1124
- § 12:2 : General Concerns with Employee Blogging and Social Networking1125
- § 12:3 : Ownership of Blog/Social Media Content1126
- § 12:4 : Sources of Protection for Employees and Employer Liability1128
- § 12:4.1 : National Labor Relations Act1128
- [A] : Scope of Protected “Concerted Activity”1128
- [B] : Recent NLRB Decisions1129
- [C] : Recent Guidance from the NLRB?s Office of the General Counsel1130
- § 12:4.2 : Federal Trade Commission Regulations1132
- § 12:4.3 : Negligent Supervision Liability1133
- § 12:4.4 : Whistleblower and Retaliation Laws1133
- § 12:4.5 : Equal Employment Opportunity Laws1135
- [A] : Employees’ Protected Information Online1135
- [B] : Nondiscriminatory Investigation and Enforcement1136
- [C] : Social Media and Hiring Decisions1136
- § 12:4.6 : Restrictive Covenants1137
- § 12:4.7 : State Off-Duty Conduct Laws1138
- [A] : New York Labor Law1139
- [B] : California Labor Law1140
- § 12:4.8 : Privacy-Related Laws1141
- § 12:4.9 : New Laws Prohibiting Employers’ Access to Employees’ Social Media Sites1142
- § 12:5 : Litigation Issues1144
- § 12:5.1 : Scope of Discoverability of Blogs and Social Media1144
- § 12:5.2 : Methods of Discovering Blogs and Social Media1146
- § 12:5.3 : Limitations of Attorney Research Using Blogs and Social Networking Sites1147
- § 12:5.4 : Publicizing Litigation Proceedings via Blogs and Social Networks1148
|
|
Chapter 13: |
Family, Medical, and Military Leave: Recent Developments Under the FMLA and USERRA |
|
|
- § 13:1 : Introduction1151
- § 13:2 : FMLA and Interpreting Regulations1153
- § 13:2.1 : Basic Requirements1153
- [A] : “Covered Employer”1153
- [A][1] : Applicable Regulations1153
- [A][2] : Selected Cases1154
- [B] : “Successor in Interest”1155
- [B][1] : Applicable Regulations1155
- [B][2] : Selected Cases1156
- [C] : “Eligible Employee”1156
- [C][1] : Applicable Regulations1156
- [C][2] : Selected Cases1158
- [D] : Reasons for Leave1160
- [D][1] : Applicable Regulations1160
- [D][2] : Selected Cases1162
- [E] : Amount of Leave Entitlement1163
- [E][1] : Applicable Regulations1163
- [E][2] : Selected Cases1165
- [F] : Serious Health Condition1165
- [F][1] : Applicable Regulations1165
- [F][2] : Selected Cases1166
- § 13:2.2 : Employee’s Obligation to Provide Notice of Need for Leave1167
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1167
- [B] : Selected Cases1169
- § 13:2.3 : Employer’s Obligation to Designate Leave and to Provide Notice of Rights1173
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1173
- [B] : Selected Cases1175
- § 13:2.4 : Healthcare Provider’s Certification1176
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1176
- [B] : Selected Cases1178
- § 13:2.5 : Substitution of Paid Leave1181
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1181
- [B] : Selected Cases1182
- § 13:2.6 : Continuation of Health Insurance1183
- § 13:2.7 : Intermittent and Reduced Leave Schedules Under the FMLA1184
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1184
- [B] : Selected Cases1185
- § 13:2.8 : Right to Reinstatement1185
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1185
- [B] : Selected Cases1187
- § 13:2.9 : Prohibition of Interference, Discrimination, or Retaliation1189
- [A] : Applicable Regulations1189
- [B] : Selected Cases: Discrimination and Retaliation1190
- [C] : Selected Cases: Interference1195
- § 13:2.10 : Eleventh Amendment Sovereign Immunity1199
- § 13:2.11 : Statute of Limitations1201
- [A] : Applicable Statute1201
- [B] : Selected Cases1201
- § 13:2.12 : Personal Liability1201
- § 13:2.13 : Relief Available Under the FMLA1203
- [A] : Applicable Regulation1203
- [B] : Selected Cases1203
- § 13:2.14 : Waiver of Rights Under the FMLA1205
- [A] : Applicable Regulation1205
- [B] : Selected Cases1206
- § 13:2.15 : Miscellaneous Issues1208
- [A] : Arbitration of FMLA Claims1208
- [B] : FMLA Preemption1208
- [C] : Bankruptcy Estoppel1208
- [D] : Exacerbation Claims Under the FMLA1209
- § 13:3 : Military Leave1210
- § 13:3.1 : Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 19941210
- [A] : Important Concepts Under USERRA1211
- [B] : Reemployment Rights1212
- [B][1] : Employee’s Responsibility to Provide Documentation of Service1213
- [B][2] : Returning Employees’ Employment Rights1213
- [B][3] : Disabled Employees’ Rights Under USERRA1214
- [B][4] : Selected Cases1215
- [C] : Changed Circumstances1217
- [D] : Compensation and Benefits1217
- [E] : Prohibition on Discrimination and Acts of Reprisal1218
- [E][1] : Important Concepts1218
- [E][2] : Selected Cases1219
- [F] : Release of USERRA Claims1222
- [G] : Arbitration of USERRA Claims1222
- [H] : Eleventh Amendment Sovereign Immunity and State Law Preemption—Selected Cases1223
|
|
Chapter 14: |
Arbitration |
|
|
- § 14:1 : Introduction1226
- § 14:2 : Class Action Arbitration and Waivers1228
- § 14:2.1 : Whether Arbitration of Class Claims Is Permissible1228
- § 14:2.2 : The Enforceability of Class Action Waivers1233
- [A] : General Principles and Concepcion1233
- [B] : The Impact of Concepcion in California1238
- [C] : Impact of Concepcion Outside of California1240
- [D] : Concepcion and the National Labor Relations Act1242
- § 14:2.3 : Whether Federal Statutory and State Law Employment Claims Are Arbitrable1245
- [A] : Title VII1245
- [B] : Age Discrimination in Employment Act and the Waiver Restrictions of the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act1247
- [C] : Fair Labor Standards Act1249
- [D] : Sarbanes-Oxley1250
- [E] : USERRA Claims1252
- [F] : State Law Claims1253
- § 14:3 : Whether an Arbitration Agreement Will Be Given Full Effect If It Does Not Provide All Available Statutory Remedies1255
- § 14:3.1 : Background1255
- § 14:3.2 : Punitive Damages1256
- § 14:3.3 : Attorney Fees1258
- § 14:3.4 : Equitable Relief1259
- § 14:4 : Enforceability of Arbitration Agreements1260
- § 14:4.1 : Whether Arbitration Agreements in Employment Documents, Contracts, Partnership Agreements, and Employee Handbooks Are Enforceable1260
- § 14:4.2 : Whether the Agreement to Arbitrate Must Be Knowing and Voluntary1262
- § 14:4.3 : Whether an Agreement to Arbitrate Is an Unconscionable Contract of Adhesion1265
- [A] : Procedural Unconscionability1265
- [B] : Substantive Unconscionability1267
- § 14:4.4 : Whether the Employer Must Pay All Arbitration Costs1269
- § 14:4.5 : Whether Arbitration Agreements Are Enforceable by Third Parties1271
- § 14:5 : EEOC Litigation on Behalf of Employee Subject to an Agreement to Arbitrate1273
- § 14:6 : Questions of Arbitrability: Who Decides?1275
- § 14:7 : The Scope of Judicial Review of Arbitration Awards1281
- § 14:7.1 : Limited Grounds for Vacating an Arbitration Award1281
- § 14:7.2 : “Manifest Disregard of the Law”1282
- § 14:7.3 : Other Grounds for Judicial Review1284
- § 14:8 : Whether the Right to Compel Arbitration Can Be Waived1288
- § 14:9 : Conclusion1290
|
|
|
Table of Cases |
|
|
|
|
Index to Employment Law Yearbook 2013 |
|
|